CLAIM 2024 Checklist

Section / Topic No. Item Page / Line No No NA
TITLE / ABSTRACT
1 Identification as a study of AI methodology, specifying the category of technology used (e.g., deep learning)
ABSTRACT
2 Summary of study design, methods, results, and conclusions
INTRODUCTION
3 Scientific and/or clinical background, including the intended use and role of the AI approach
4 Study aims, objectives, and hypotheses
METHODS
Study Design 5 Prospective or retrospective study
6 Study goal
Data 7 Data sources
8 Inclusion and exclusion criteria
9 Data pre-processing
10 Selection of data subsets
11 De-identification methods
12 How missing data were handled
13 Image acquisition protocol
Reference Standard 14 Definition of method(s) used to obtain reference standard
15 Rationale for choosing the reference standard
16 Source of reference standard annotations
17 Annotation of test set
18 Measures of inter- and intra-rater variability of features described by the annotators
Data Partitions 19 How data were assigned to partitions
20 Level at which partitions are disjoint
Testing Data 21 Intended sample size
Model 22 Detailed description of model
23 Software libraries, frameworks, and packages
24 Initialization of model parameters
Training 25 Details of training approach
26 Method of selecting the final model
27 Ensembling techniques
Evaluation 28 Metrics of model performance
29 Statistical measures of significance and uncertainty
30 Robustness or sensitivity analysis
31 Methods for explainability or interpretability
32 Evaluation on internal data
33 Testing on external data
34 Clinical trial registration
RESULTS
Data 35 Numbers of patients or examinations included and excluded
36 Demographic and clinical characteristics of cases in each partition
Model performance 37 Performance metrics and measures of statistical uncertainty
38 Estimates of diagnostic performance and their precision
39 Failure analysis of incorrect results
DISCUSSION
40 Study limitations
41 Implications for practice, including intended use and/or clinical role
OTHER INFORMATION
42 Provide a reference to the full study protocol or to additional technical details
43 Statement about the availability of software, trained model, and/or data
44 Sources of funding and other support; role of funders

* Indicate page and/or line number for each checklist item that is present. NA = not applicable.

Tejani AS, Klontzas ME, Gatti AA, et al. Checklist for Artificial Intelligence in Medical Imaging (CLAIM):2024 Update. Radiol Artif Intell 2024;6(4):e240300. https://doi.org/10.1148/ryai.240300


This site uses Just the Docs, a documentation theme for Jekyll.